Tuesday, April 1, 2014

Alcott vs. Austen

Photo Credit Here
I’m a huge fan of Louisa May Alcott.  I have been since I was eleven years old, and read Little Women for the first time.  Jo March was (and still is) the coolest character ever with her temper, independent ways, and love of the written word.  Once I wandered into Jo’s world, I was forevermore an Alcott fan. 


I’m on my second copy of LittleWomen because my first copy literally fell apart from having been carried around so much, and read so many times.  I usually re-read it at least once a year. 

Jane Austen, on the other hand, is an author whose books I have never been able to get into.  I’ve tried, I really, really have. I make it about 25 – 30 pages in, and then I just can’t take it anymore.   I give up and move on to a book I enjoy.  I don’t know what it is, but I’ve never read something of hers and wanted to read more.

Friends and family tell me I “should” like Jane Austen’s books, and that I’m the Jane Austen “type”.  I’ve been given dozens of copies of various Jane Austen novels over the years, and they’ve all made their way to thrift stores, or used bookstores in trade for other books.

It really bugs me to be told I’m the Jane Austen “type” since I don’t like her books, but it also bugs me that there doesn’t seem to be (or at least I’ve never heard about) a Louisa May Alcott “type”.  Maybe none of us are cool enough to be typed as the creators of Jo March. 


I just think it seems like Jane Austen gets a lot more attention than Louisa May Alcott as a great author whose books you simply must read, despite the fact that Alcott’s books are much better than Austen’s.    So where do you stand on the matter of Alcott vs. Austen?  Are you a fan of either?  Both?  Neither? 

20 comments:

  1. I've always loved Louisa May Alcott. Like you, I read Little Women again and again. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I knew I liked you! :-) I just love Little Women; I think it's one I could never get tired of.

      Delete
  2. I'm with you on Louisa May Alcott. I have her book, Under the Lilacs, on my Kindle. Have you read it?
    Also, I tried to read Pride and Prejudice when I was a teen. Never got far. I should give it another try, but my reading list is already so long ...
    Best,
    Deb@ http://debioneille.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I haven't read Under the Lilacs yet. It's on the Kindle, but I'm NOT a fan of the Kindle, so I've kind of been putting it off. I want to read it, I just don't want to use the Kindle right now.

      Delete
  3. I am a Jane Austen fan but I haven't read all her books. I think she gets a lot of attention because she wrote about independent minded women in a time when that was unacceptable. Her protagonists were intelligent women fighting a polite war against the restrictions of their time. Does that sound like you?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That makes sense as to why Jane Austen gets a lot of attention, though I do think the same can be said for some of Louisa May Alcott's characters. I suppose we should be glad they both pursued their writing and paved the way for female authors to write strong women.

      Delete
  4. I fall on the side of Austen. Susan Gourley rally summed it up well for me above. :)

    And agree whole-heartedly with your response to her.:)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Awesome, we can agree to disagree on Alcott vs. Austen, but agree on other points. :-)

      Delete
  5. I don't really fall on the side of either. I'm a terrible reader girl and don't really love a lot of the classics (probably a lot to do with not liking being forced to read things because someone tells me too--yeah I totally don't like authority lol)

    But I've read both and have both at the house. I've read some Austen I enjoyed but others eh not so much. I haven't tried Alcott as an adult though I remember reading Little Women long, long ago.

    Happy A to Z-ing!
    ~Anna
    My A to Z.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, I'm not a big fan of being forced to read anything, even if it is considered a classic. There are enough books out there for there to be something for everyone without forcing any on anyone.

      Good luck with A to Z!

      Delete
  6. This is terrible to admit, but I haven't read any books by either author. I do know that my sister was a big Little Women fan. Maybe I'll have to put these authors on my to read list after the A/Z challenge.

    betty

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's not terrible, there are just A LOT of books out there, so everyone has quite a few they haven't gotten to yet. I do highly recommend trying Louisa May Alcott though. :-)

      Delete
  7. As much as I love to read, I can't say that I have read a Jane Austen...or have I? Hmmm... I shall put both on my summer reading list and let you know! :)

    ReplyDelete
  8. I love them both (I was always such a Jo fan), but I'm an Austen girl at heart.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I can't imagine anyone not being a Jo fan. I've just never found an Austen character that I could love as much I love Jo.

      Delete
  9. Funny! I am definitely Alcott over Austen. And yet, because I studied the late 18th century in grad school, people were sure I'd love Austen. I have multiple boxes of Jane Austen band aids, fancy copies of her book, and a "I'd rather be reading Jane Austen" bumper sticker. Yet, like you, I can't finish a book.

    But, truth be told, while I like Alcott, and her father Bronson, I am more of an L. M. Montgomery girl than any other.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Isn't it odd how people just decide that you like (or love) an author for whatever reason, and then just run with that?

      I'm not sure how I feel about Bronson. I read one biography on Louisa that cast him in a really bad light. I probably need to read more about him

      I've never been able to get into the Anne of Green Gables books, but I didn't realize she had so many other books until now. I may have to try some of the other ones.

      I can't seem to find your blog. Any chance you can leave the link?

      Delete
  10. I love them both! But find it "easier" to read Alcott...I see what you're saying about Austen, it does take perseverance and determination. Gail

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I guess I've just never had the perseverance to finish an Auten novel.

      Delete

Thank you for taking the time to comment! Please leave your link so I can visit you as well.